A South African appeal court has dismissed Nigerian national Sunday Okoro’s latest attempt to revive a R5.41m (approximately N430m) damages claim over his arrest and 117-day detention in connection with a murder investigation.
The Supreme Court of Appeal rejected Okoro’s reconsideration application after his earlier attempts to obtain permission to appeal against the dismissal of his case were unsuccessful.
Also read19 killed as Russian military transport plane crashes in Siberia
According to South African news outlet IOL, the dispute stemmed from Okoro’s arrest on July 3, 2002, following the discovery of a man’s body hanging in the shower of room seven at Evaleigh Court, an apartment building in Durban.
Okoro was said to have rented the apartment days before the discovery.
He remained in police custody until November 29, 2002, when prosecutors withdrew the murder charges against him.
After his release, he instituted legal proceedings against the Minister of Police, seeking R5.41m in compensation for what he described as unlawful arrest and detention, alongside the losses and suffering he experienced.
The KwaZulu-Natal High Court in Durban dismissed the claim with costs, ruling that the police had reasonable grounds to suspect him of murder and that his arrest and detention were lawful.
Okoro subsequently sought permission to appeal, but both the High Court and the Supreme Court of Appeal declined his requests.
He then approached the president of the appeal court, seeking reconsideration of the matter.
The application was considered by a three-member panel comprising Acting Judges of Appeal Mjali and Molitsoane, and Judge of Appeal Nicholls.
In its decision, the majority, consisting of Molitsoane and Nicholls, dismissed the application with costs.
The court heard evidence from Warrant Officers Allen Mark Naidu and Sunil Seosunker, who were conducting crime-prevention duties in Durban’s Point area when they encountered Okoro outside Evaleigh Court.
Naidu reportedly testified that Okoro entered the building after noticing their police vehicle, prompting the officers to follow him.
The officer later saw Okoro emerging from room seven in a distressed condition and repeatedly calling out the name Francine.
Okoro reportedly asked the officers to accompany him into the room, where they discovered the deceased, a man of Indian descent, hanging by a bedsheet in the shower.
Naidu said the body was cold and stiff, with no pulse.
He suspected that the hanging might have been staged to conceal a murder because the deceased’s feet were not positioned close enough to the shower ledge to suggest that he had used it to hang himself.
The court, however, found no evidence that the police had misled prosecutors or deliberately withheld or distorted information to keep Okoro in custody.
It consequently ruled that there was no legal basis to hold the Minister of Police responsible for his detention after his first court appearance.
Also read19 killed as Russian military transport plane crashes in Siberia
According to the report, the R5.41m claim was equivalent to approximately N430m at an exchange rate of R1 to N79.48 at the time PUNCH filed its report.
Peculiar Adirika is a journalist and contributor to Freelanews.com, covering news, business, and public affairs.
























